Skip to content
NovaSpacePlus

Why Caicedo Received a Red Card While Bentancur Escaped: An Analysis of Seeming Lack of Uniformity.

A Chelsea side down to ten men The Blues hold the Gunners to a tie in feisty London derby.

Chelsea boss Maresca was left frustrated. Not because of the dismissal of his midfielder against Arsenal, but over what he perceived to be a glaring lack of consistency from the officials.

It's easy to understand his point. In a previous fixture, Tottenham midfielder Rodrigo Bentancur was booked for a challenge on Reece James, a ruling the video review system upheld. However, when the Ecuadorian was given a yellow for a seemingly similar challenge on Mikel Merino, the VAR intervened to recommend a red card.

"That is a sending-off offence, but why was Bentancur's on Reece James not a red card? So us, as a manager, we find it difficult to comprehend why they judge in a dissimilar manner," Maresca stated.

Analyzing the Distinction?

Ultimately, rulings are often influenced upon the specific official on VAR duty—a factor that renders true consistency exceptionally challenging.

Each incident is unique, and there were subtle differences between the pair of tackles. Bentancur was largely making a standing challenge, whereas the Chelsea man left the ground slightly and his point of contact was slightly higher.

There was also a visible twist of the midfielder's joint, a sign a video referee watches for to signal undue severity, and his boot was shifted on the turf.

Regarding the earlier incident, the league's independent review panel backed the caution for the player by a margin of 4-1, and unanimously backed no VAR intervention "on the basis that the tackle was low, marginally tardy and reckless".

This same panel will undoubtedly back the decision to send off Caicedo, but it won't be too long before another tackle of its type is judged only a booking.

Was the Video Official Instruct the Referee to Issue a Caution?

The Chelsea midfielder will be banned for three games following his red card against the North London side.

Events on the field seemed somewhat perplexing at first. Did official Taylor being told to caution the player so the incident could be reviewed?

There is a far simpler reason.

Taylor allowed play to continue for the attacking team as the loose ball was with a Gunners player. Once the ball left play for a throw, the referee went back to book the offender, who was receiving treatment. Officials are instructed to delay until an player at fault is back on their feet before displaying a card.

Therefore, the pause was not due to the VAR was checking; it was because Caicedo was being treated.

The VAR John Brooks can reach the determination that there was sufficient severity for a red, but he must await for Taylor to indicate his initial decision. As soon as he brandished a yellow, the video official promptly instructed him to the review screen because the assessment had already taken place during the medical stoppage.

England Rejects Sending-Off VAR Recommendation

In another Sunday match, for just the second instance in the Premier League, a referee overturned a red card review at the pitchside monitor.

The referee hadn't given a foul against Jhon Arias, so in contrast to the Arsenal incident, the restart was a set piece to Aston Villa. The VAR, James Bell, felt that the way the player launched himself with both feet compromised the opponent's safety.

However, Arias was in the air and took a risk, making contact with the upper part of the player's foot. It did not have the level of intensity typically required for a red card, even if it was not a great challenge.

Was There a Case For Chelsea's Opening Goal to Be Disallowed for Offside?

Video review decided that the Argentine did not interfere on the defenders when Chalobah headed in the first goal for Chelsea.

Another weekend, and another series of debatable rulings on player positioning.

One potential offside on the Blues' opener seems to have gone under the radar.

Reece James floated a corner in from the left, and Trevoh Chalobah guided a header into the back of the net.

But there was a potential issue. Enzo Fernandez was stood in an illegal position and was very close to Arsenal's Piero Hincapie and Cristhian Mosquera.

Did Fernandez influence the actions of either defender? If the Chelsea midfielder been absent, would there have been a better chance of preventing the header?

Fernandez made no attempt to play the ball, and while he was not physically contesting with Mosquera, he had his arm on the other's shoulder.

You can make a very strong case for an offside call, so it comes back to a question of consistency once again.

Did Hincapie Deserve Red for an Use of the Elbow?

Piero Hincapie started for Arsenal with both centre-backs unavailable through fitness issues.

It was shortly after the Caicedo sending-off. Hincapie jumped for a ball with the Chelsea player, and the Blues man sustained contact through an impact by the elbow on his head.

"I questioned the official, he told me that it was not an elbow," Maresca explained. "That was what they ruled. Chalobah suffered a facial injury, with an ice pack at the interval. But they judge in a separate manner."

Match officials are advised not to make decisions based on a potential injury, though it undoubtedly happens. A footballer can sustain a gash or a contusion from various types of challenges, so it would not be logical.

Similar to serious foul play, officials have a mental checklist they assess for a potential elbow offence.

  • Was it an unnatural way of going for a aerial ball?
  • Did the player a closed fist, suggesting malicious intent?
  • Was the elbow thrown or lifted to create force?

None of these applied, so a caution was considered appropriate.

About the author

Matthew Lane

Astrophysicist and science communicator passionate about making space accessible to all.

NovaSpacePlus

Type to search articles.